Z-Wave Alliance

The Internet of Things is powered by Z-Wave.

Follow Us On Social Media! FacebookFollow Us On Social Media! TwitterFollow Us On Social Media! LinkedInFollow Us On Social Media! YouTube
Member Login  
Over 3,600 products.
All interoperable with each other.

The Smart Home is powered by Z-Wave.

  • Home
  • About Us
    • Alliance Overview
    • Z-Wave Alliance Vision And Mission
    • Our History
    • Our Services
    • Board of Directors
    • Legal
  • About Z-Wave
    • Z-Wave Global Regions
    • Z-Wave Technology
    • For OEMs & Developers
    • For Integrators
    • For Consumers
    • Z-Wave Specifications
  • Certification
    • Z-Wave Certification Overview
    • Z-Wave Certification Tutorials
    • Z-Wave Interoperability
    • Certification News Archive
  • Products
    • Catalog of Certified Z-Wave Products
    • Certified Installer Toolkit (CIT) Support Change
  • Markets
    • Smart Security
    • Connected Aging
    • Energy Management
    • Home Management
  • Membership
    • Member Companies
    • Find A Z-Wave Installer
    • How To Join
  • News
    • Z-Wave In The News
    • Alliance Press Releases
    • Member Press Releases
    • International Releases
    • Z-Wave Blog
  • Events
    • Z-Wave @ Light + Building 2022
    • Z-Wave @ CEDIA 2022
    • Z-Wave @ CES 2023
  • Training &
    Education
You are here: Home / Z-Wave Blog / Why Sub-GHz Continues to be a Critical Piece of the Smart Home Puzzle

Why Sub-GHz Continues to be a Critical Piece of the Smart Home Puzzle

As the diversity of smart home devices and solutions continues to grow—making our lives ever more convenient and connected—understanding the communications framework underpinning them is more important than ever. We sat down with Mariusz Malkowski, director of customer success and integration, Building36 Technologies to discuss his thoughts on why sub-GHz frequencies continue to be a critical aspect of smart home technology, as well as the future outlook for devices and solutions making use of sub-GHz.

The Genesis of the Smart Home

Ask Malkowski how long smart home technology has relied on the sub-GHz layer to communicate, and he will tell you that we first need to establish when the “smart home” really started.

“I think the breaking point for smart home was the iPhone in 2007, when consumers started wanting to do more with their handheld devices,” he said. “You will find devices 20-30 years ago that were in a smart home space, but they were probably not called smart home back then. Instead, ‘home automation’ was the big word. Back then, you could get a smart home system installed for a couple hundred thousand dollars, but it has since become much more reliable and more affordable.”

Since those early days of home automation, a proliferation of proprietary and standards-based solutions has offered consumers a variety of options on both the 2.4GHz and sub-GHz layers. Only sub-GHz, however, provides the fundamental advantages of a longer range, longer battery life, better reliability, and reduced crowding.

Maximizing Range and Battery Life

“Given the same power budget—the same amount of energy used—you’re going to get about double the range from Z-Wave when compared to 2.4GHz, and that’s just down to the physics of it,” Malkowski explained. “Now, that gets thrown out the window with Z-Wave long-range, where your typical range is going to be about a mile, and on 2.4GHz you’re lucky to get 300 feet. The lower the frequency, the better the range, the better the penetration.”

A white paper published by Austin, Texas-based Silicon Laboratories expanded on this particular advantage of sub-GHz. It cited three main reasons for better range performance over 2.4GHz applications: “As radio waves pass through walls and other obstacles, the signal weakens. Attenuation rates increase at higher frequencies, therefore the 2.4GHz signal weakens faster than a sub-GHz signal.” Secondly, it said, “2.4GHz radio waves also fade more quickly than sub-GHz waves as they reflect off dense surfaces. In highly congested environments, the 2.4GHz transmission can weaken rapidly, which adversely affects signal quality.” And finally, it said, “Though radio waves travel in a straight line, they do bend when they hit a solid edge. As frequencies decrease, the angle of diffraction increases, allowing sub-GHz signals to bend farther around an obstacle, reducing the blocking effect.”

With regards to battery longevity, Malkowski explained that sub-GHz frequencies can support up to double that of comparable 2.4GHz devices, without replacement. “The same door lock from a given manufacturer with a radio frequency at 900MHz—you’re probably going get about 18 to 24 months before needing to replace that. For 2.4GHz on the other hand, because of the nature of the communication, it’s going to be about 12 to 16 months,” he said.

To this point, the Silicon Laboratories white paper explained, “The sensitivity is inversely proportional to channel bandwidth, so a narrower bandwidth creates higher receiver sensitivity and allows efficient operation at lower transmission rates.” It continued, “In general, all radio circuits running at higher frequencies … need more current to achieve the same performance as lower frequencies.”

An Open, Reliable Highway

Take a moment to count the number of Wi-Fi- or Bluetooth-enabled devices in your home. When you consider that your computer, smart phone, smart speaker, smart TV, gaming consoles, remote controls—even, occasionally, your microwave—are all competing to operate over 2.4 GHz, it’s easy to understand how things can get a bit congested.

The sub-GHz layer, on the other hand, does not suffer from the same amount of traffic, explained Malkowski: “The more devices you have within the same space in 2.4GHz, the less reliability, potentially. That’s why being in sub-GHz is so important.”

This sentiment was echoed by the Silicon Laboratories white paper, which stated, “Sub-GHz ISM [industrial, scientific, and medical] bands are mostly used for proprietary, low-duty-cycle links and are not as likely to interfere with each other. The quieter spectrum means easier transmissions and fewer retries, which is more efficient and saves battery power.”

Another facet of greater sub-GHz reliability is reduced latency. Malkowski explained, “With respect to latency—or how fast you can talk to devices—you can open a Z-Wave door lock within two seconds, and that’s the worst case. In ZigBee or OpenThread, on the other hand, it would be eight to 10 seconds. Does that difference really matter? Sometimes it does, sometimes it doesn’t.”

Malkowski summarized the advantages of sub-GHz frequencies using an analogy: “On the sub-GHz layer, I’m getting the experience of being on a six-lane highway packed with cars, and I’m just cruising by myself in the left lane.” He emphasized that reliability, as well as a lack of interference with other devices, will ultimately be critical to the future advancement of smart home solutions.

Different Countries, Different Frequencies

The most commonly cited disadvantage of sub-GHz is that frequencies need to be re-adjusted based on the country you are in. “Companies that are using technologies other than Z-Wave—they very often point out that it’s not a global solution,” Malkowski said. “With ZigBee or OpenThread we can make one device and sell it all over the world, but with Z-Wave that’s not possible.”

But despite the hurdle that device manufacturers face when it comes to making their products available to a global market, it is important to note that for the average smart home consumer in the United States—for whom automated lighting control and garage door openers being operable abroad is not an altogether essential feature—this constraint on sub-GHz is of limited concern.

A Future-Proof Solution

With the rapidly evolving smart home technology market, one could be forgiven for worrying that the sub-GHz layer itself will eventually become too crowded—or simply become a non-viable option for device manufacturers, whether due to some new FCC regulation or replacement by its higher-frequency counterparts.

But Malkowski is not overly concerned: “We’re seeing new additions to the sub-GHz layer like Amazon Sidewalk, but we’re still far away from where they are frequency-wise. They use what’s called spread spectrum, which allows them to jump on different frequencies. So, the probability of it becoming overcrowded is much less than 2.4, which has fixed channels. That’s the major difference.” He added, “Furthermore, it’s usually the emergency services that dictate what frequencies are available or not. I anticipate that the same bands we have access to today will still be available 20-plus years from now.”

Far from being overshadowed—sub-GHz frequencies are a faster, more reliable, and more cost-effective device communication solution that will continue to benefit smart home technology consumers for decades to come.

SEARCH

Feedback

We welcome your feedback! Please feel free to email us your thoughts and questions.

Terms of Use

Please click here to view our Terms of Use.

Data Privacy & Cookie Policy

Please click here to view our Data Privacy & Cookie Policy.

Silicon Labs

Visit Silicon Labs to learn more about the company behind the Z-Wave Technology.

To report a Z-Wave security issue click here.

Z-Wave.com

Consumers can visit Z-Wave.com to learn more about Z-Wave, its many benefits, and how to get started using Z-Wave in your home.

Copyright © 2022 Z-Wave Alliance, All rights reserved.

The Z-Wave Alliance | 3855 SW 153rd Drive, Beaverton, OR 97003 USA | Tel: +1.503.619.0851


The Z-Wave® trademark and Z-Wave specification are owned by Z-Wave Alliance. The information stated in this website is for reference only and should not be relied upon for technical or other purposes. The Z-Wave Alliance provides no warranty or guarantee on any part of the Z-Wave technology and disclaims all implied warranties concerning the accuracy or timeliness of information presented on this website.

This site uses cookies to improve user experience and stores information on your computer. By continuing to use our site, you consent to our Cookie Policy. If you do not want to enable cookies, review our policy and learn how they can be disabled. Note that disabling cookies will disable some features of the site.Accept Policy
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT