The U.S. Cyber Trust Mark (USCTM) program, a voluntary cybersecurity product labelling program first announced in 2023, has made major strides toward implementation in the past several weeks. The FCC is now forecasting that U.S. consumers will begin seeing products bearing the USCTM label on shelves by late 2027.
The Z-Wave Alliance recently sat down with Grace Burkard, Director of Operations at ioXt Alliance, the new lead administrator of the U.S. Cyber Trust Mark program, for an update on what has been accomplished and what’s still to come. Burkard shared insights into how this program will benefit both consumers and device manufacturers, and what manufacturers can do right now to contribute to a strong, effective program and prepare for its launch.
What is the U.S. Cyber Trust Mark Program?
The U.S. Cyber Trust Mark is a voluntary, national cybersecurity label for consumer smart devices. It’s for the gadgets consumers find in the home and interact with personally, like smart fridges, smart vacuums, video doorbells, smart locks and security devices, baby monitors, and smart TVs.
It doesn’t cover all IoT devices: Industrial, enterprise, medical and automotive devices are all outside the purview of the program. This is strictly for the products you’d find on a retail shelf and bring home.
Plenty of products already do security well, but consumers don’t have an easy way to verify this. The U.S. Cyber Trust Mark program provides a cohesive certification that covers the whole United States. Other countries are already undertaking similar efforts: for example, the EU has the Cyber Resilience Act, and Singapore has its Cybersecurity Labelling Scheme. The Cyber Trust Mark establishes a baseline for the U.S., so consumers can tell at a glance whether a device has met industry-standard cybersecurity requirements.
How will the U.S. Cyber Trust Mark Program help consumers?
Right now, it’s hard for consumers to assess if a product is secure. Is the average homeowner going to conduct cybersecurity testing or research before buying a smart plug? No, and that burden shouldn’t be on consumers in any case.
When a product carries the Cyber Trust Mark, consumers will know it has been through rigorous testing by third-party labs. Accredited CyberLabs will test products against a long list of test cases. Crucially, they will test the mobile app and cloud services as well as the device itself. Connected products are more than hardware, and the U.S. Cyber Trust Mark program covers the whole thing.
Of course, the Cyber Trust Mark cannot be a 100% guarantee of security. Threats evolve and new vulnerabilities emerge constantly, so nothing could ever guarantee a connected product will be perfectly secure forever. But it does empower consumers to make a more informed judgment about device security before they buy.
The U.S. Cyber Trust Mark is a binary label: A product either has the mark or it doesn’t, so it’s easy to recognize and understand. Consumers will also be able to scan a QR code on the device packaging for more detailed information.
How does participating in the U.S. Cyber Trust Mark Program benefit brands bringing connected products to market?
Americans are increasingly concerned about the privacy and security of their connected devices, and they’re willing to pay more for products with stronger protections. The Cyber Trust Mark gives brands an instant, differentiating signal that a device was designed to protect consumers’ data.
ioXt is overseeing a multistakeholder process to develop the Consumer Education and Awareness Plan for FCC approval. Manufacturers, alliances, industry organizations and retailers will all be part of making sure consumers know what the label means and why choosing secure products benefits them.
Retailers are key participants who will provide central messaging straight to consumers. They want this for their customers, and some have already talked about special placement for products bearing the mark. In stores, that could mean end caps, signage or dedicated sections. Online, it could mean designated tabs or listing those products first. Each retailer will decide for itself, but when big brands back a product as the secure choice, consumers will pay attention and start shifting the market with their purchasing power.
That’s why early participants get a head start. The first brands to secure the mark will become the recommended products for a secure smart home. As adoption grows, the U.S. Cyber Trust Mark will continue to differentiate the brands consumers can count on.
Today, people often select products based primarily on price because they have limited information on product differentiators. If one device is $2 and a comparable one is $5, and only the $5 one carries the mark, the reason for the difference is suddenly clear. On a shelf full of certified products, the one without the mark will stand out for the wrong reasons.
What is the current status of the program, and what are the next important milestones?
We’re putting uniform processes in place, with checks and balances at every step, so that the Cyber Trust Mark is a meaningful, consistently enforced standard.
On October 28, FCC Commissioner Olivia Trusty announced at CTA’s Innovation House that she will lead the Cyber Trust Mark through implementation. We’re very excited to have her overseeing the program. In an October 28 op-ed for Fox News, Commissioner Trusty affirmed that “The FCC is working to roll out the Cyber Trust Mark program to a retailer near you by next year.”
On October 27, the FCC’s Public Safety and Homeland Security Bureau released a public notice seeking comment on operational requirements including label design, certification renewal, and post-market surveillance.
Comments are due 30 days after the notice is published in the Federal Register, and reply comments are due 45 days after publication. The FCC will make rules based on this feedback, so stakeholder engagement is crucial.
The FCC has confirmed it will issue a separate public notice on technical standards and testing procedures. This is likely to be a much bigger piece than the most recent public notice: ioXt’s latest technical recommendations, which we filed with the FCC on October 26, run 127 pages, so I encourage everyone to read the draft requirements in advance.
Once the technical requirements are final, Cybersecurity Label Administrators (CLAs) and CyberLabs can complete accreditation, and then manufacturers can begin testing and certification.
Once the program is fully operational, what will the process be to get a device certified?
The process is straightforward, at least on paper:
- The manufacturer sends the device to an accredited CyberLab.
- The CyberLab tests the product. If it fails, it goes back to the device maker for updates. If it passes, it moves on to a CLA.
- The CLA reviews the results and issues the mark. A CLA can be part of the same company as a lab, and several CLAs are already labs, but the testing and review must be done by separate teams and staff. Keeping them separate holds the testing and certification results accountable, as well as the product.
- The manufacturer receives permission to use the mark, along with a QR code. They can put it on product packaging, websites, and marketing and sales materials. The FCC has proposed a three-year certification cycle, with renewed testing at each renewal.
Final details for label marketing, a product registry, and public education are still being worked out. The goal is to make sure consumers understand what the label means and can easily find products that carry it.
What can manufacturers do now to prepare for the launch of the U.S. Cyber Trust Mark program?
There are two important calls to action: help make sure the program is strong, and make sure your devices are secure.
Review the October 27 notice on label design, certification renewal and post-market surveillance, and comment with your company’s feedback. Once the initial comments are in, read them and file your replies. The FCC wants all the feedback it can get from the industry stakeholders who will be impacted by the program.
More importantly, be prepared to comment when the FCC issues its public notice on technical requirements. You can get a head start now by reviewing the ioXt technical recommendations already filed with the FCC. Some details may change after the comment process, but the core will remain consistent.
Consumer Technology Association (CTA) has also filed four technical standards that are complimentary to ioXt’s technical recommendations and the USCTM program. These standards provide practical details on label design, security of wireless protocols, deprecated technologies, and cybersecurity test reporting. Together, they can help promote consistent testing, reduce compliance burdens, and give consumers reliable information about the cybersecurity of connected products.
ioXt’s recommendations are built on NIST IR 8425, and they cover areas including asset identification, documentation, proven cryptography, automatic software updates, and software and data protection. Device makers can start working now to ensure the products they plan to submit align with these recommendations.
You may already be close to alignment; you just need to understand how your security measures map to this program. If you want to be one of the first movers, start today, and you’ll be ready to submit as soon as the program opens.